“I just refunded her because I couldn’t risk the drama on Instagram.”
“I’ve drafted a post three times, but what if she sues me for defamation?”
Sound familiar?
If you’re a coach, consultant, or expert building a business online, your reputation is everything. In fact, it’s probably the most valuable asset you own. Which is why when a client threatens to “go public” — or when someone trashes your work online — it’s more than annoying. It can be terrifying.
And that fear goes both ways. Many founders keep quiet about dodgy experiences because they don’t know if they’re legally allowed to speak out.
So, let’s get stuck in. Here’s your plain-English guide to UK defamation law, the truth about what you can and can’t say online — and what to do if someone posts something damaging about you.
✅ What Is Defamation Under UK Law?
In the UK, defamation is when someone publishes a false statement that seriously harms another person’s or business’s reputation.
There are two types:
- Libel – written or published defamation (yes, that includes tweets, Instagram posts, TikToks, and Google reviews)
- Slander – spoken defamation (e.g. spreading lies in a WhatsApp voice note or at a networking event)
To bring a defamation claim, the statement must:
- Be about you (or your identifiable business),
- Be false,
- Have caused or be likely to cause serious reputational harm.
Under the Defamation Act 2013, the threshold for “serious harm” is higher than it used to be — which means not every nasty post is legally actionable. But when it crosses the line? You’ve got options.
📢 Is It Defamation or Just a Bad Review?
Let’s break it down with some juicy real-world scenarios your audience will recognise.
1. “She threatened to ‘go public’ if I didn’t refund her.”
A mindset coach gave a full refund after receiving a DM that ended with:
“If you don’t sort this, I’ll be sharing my experience with my 15k followers.”
The programme had been delivered as promised, and there were no contractual issues. But the fear of public backlash was enough to make her cave.
🔍 Legal takeaway: This is not defamation yet, but it’s a threat that uses public shaming as leverage. If the client had published false statements, and those caused serious reputational harm, the coach could have a case.
2. “My honest post led to a solicitor’s letter.”
A nutritionist wrote a thoughtful Instagram carousel about her disappointing experience with a business coach, using only a first name. The post covered what she felt were unethical sales tactics and disappointing service.
The next day: legal letter. Accused of defamation. Post deleted. End of story.
🔍 Legal takeaway: Even without naming someone, if others can figure out who you’re talking about, defamation law still applies. Truth is a full defence, but you must be able to back it up with evidence.
3. “That 1-star review nearly broke me.”
A client left a Trustpilot review saying a leadership consultant “lied about her qualifications” and “scams people”. This wasn’t true.
The consultant reported the review, got legal advice, and requested removal — which was granted. The client eventually posted a public apology.
🔍 Legal takeaway: Factual claims like “lied” or “scam” are much riskier than opinion. If they’re provably false, it’s potentially defamatory. A review is not a free-for-all.
4. “She made cryptic TikToks — and I still didn’t sleep.”
A client posted vague, negative TikToks after a refund request was refused:
“Imagine paying thousands to be ignored and invalidated. Wild.”
No names, but she followed the coach, tagged similar services, and stirred up speculation.
The coach didn’t sue, but she did report the posts, update her contracts, and tightened her refund process. Smart move.
🔍 Legal takeaway: Even vague posts can be damaging if they’re widely shared and clearly hint at who you are. But not all harmful content meets the legal threshold for serious harm — so weigh your response.
3 Defamation Myths That Need To Do One…
Let’s clear up some common misconceptions that keep small business owners stuck.
❌ “If I don’t name them, I’m safe.”
If people can work out who you’re talking about, even without naming them, you could still be liable.
❌ “It’s just my opinion – I can say what I want.”
Not quite. If your “opinion” implies underlying facts (e.g. “I believe she forged her testimonials”), you could be in hot water unless those facts are true.
❌ “I deleted it so it doesn’t count.”
If someone saw it — and especially if they screenshotted or shared it — the damage may already be done.
What To Do If Someone Posts a Defamatory Comment About You Online
Here’s your step-by-step playbook for when the panic sets in:
1. Screenshot everything
Capture the post, the account, comments, and time/date. Don’t assume it’ll still be there later.
2. Check if it’s actually defamatory
Is the claim false? Can you prove it? Has it already caused serious reputational harm? Or is it just unpleasant feedback?
3. Don’t retaliate publicly
Do not respond emotionally or post your own “setting the record straight” video. Pause. Breathe. Get guidance (ideally from your affordable, fixed cost Legal Buddy membership rather than a lawyer charging an expensive hourly rate…)
4. Request a takedown
Use this message as a template:
Hi [Name],
I’ve seen your recent post/comment about my business. The claims made are untrue and damaging to my professional reputation. I’m asking that the content be removed immediately.
If this isn’t resolved by [insert deadline], I may need to explore legal options.
I hope we can sort this informally. Please let me know.
5. Report the content
Platforms like Instagram, Facebook, Google, and Trustpilot all have tools for reporting defamatory content.
6. Consider legal support
If the comment is serious and widespread, a solicitor’s letter can be a powerful move. Although you don’t need to hire a solicitor to send a Defamation Cease and Desist Letter – a template that we have in our Leal Buddy membership. You don’t have to take someone to court to assert your rights.
7. Protect yourself going forward
Review your refund terms, contracts, and onboarding process (all things we can help you with in Legal Buddy). Build in buffers, disclaimers, and documentation. Don’t give keyboard warriors free ammunition.
What Can You Legally Say About Someone Online?
✅ You can say:
- Honest feedback based on your personal experience
- Opinions that don’t make false factual claims
- Statements backed up by evidence
- Comments made with balance and fairness
🚫 You should avoid:
- Accusing someone of lying, scamming, or criminal conduct without proof
- Inviting public pile-ons
- Letting emotion lead your post
- Assuming “freedom of speech” protects you – it doesn’t cover false or harmful statements
Final Word: You Can Speak Up – But Do It Smart
UK defamation law is not designed to silence people — it’s there to protect reputation. You’re allowed to share your experience. But if you’re going to talk, talk with evidence.
And if someone else is talking about you and getting it wrong? You don’t have to sit there and take it.
Need Help?
Want a refund policy that stops nightmare clients in their tracks? Need support dealing with a defamatory post? That’s what the Legal Buddy membership is for — legal templates, fast legal support, and peace of mind, all in one place.